Our Community

Stainless steel water bottles are not all created equal!

Reusable metal water bottles are popping up for sale all over the place these days. At the Go Green Festival in New York City last April, I spotted a stainless steel bottle for $27. At local grocery stores, I’ve seen metal bottles for just $10. Custom logoed bottles can cost anywhere between $3.00 and $13.00. So what’s the difference? It turns out, plenty.

I’m sure you’ve heard the old saying: you get what you pay for.  There are some serious quality issues with the cheap metal bottles – we know because we tested lots of them in the process of choosing a bottle for Back2Tap. We encountered leaking caps, paint that literally peeled off after a few weeks, logos that were printed poorly and faded quickly, thin walls that dented very easily, and poor polishing/finishing on the bottle.

Then there’s the question of what the bottles are made of – a cheap bottle may not be made of food grade materials. If you choose stainless steel rather than aluminum, you won’t have to worry about a cheap liner that may allow unwanted constituents to leach into your beverage. Back2Tap bottles are 0.5mm thick, printed with safe and resilient paints in the USA, and are tested to ensure that they comply with FDA and ASTM standards.

An acquaintance of mine sheepishly admitted to me recently that she had supplied her whole swim team with cheap stainless steel water bottles last winter, and now regrets it. The bottles are so junky no one wants to use them anymore! At the Watchung Hills Green Day event in October, a customer who bought a stainless water bottle at our exhibit table admitted that she had just purchased a cheaper steel water bottle at another table. She bought it solely to support the soccer team even though she knew she would never actually use such a poor quality product.

These two stories highlight the main reason Back2Tap doesn't offer cheap reusable bottles – and we have considered doing so, believe me!   Plenty of suppliers have contacted us hawking their wares. Low quality bottles just don’t perform well and don’t last so they are not durable and useful, key requirements for sustainable products. Back2Tap doesn’t want to be fostering a throw- away mentality by selling cheap stainless steel water bottles because that is exactly what we are trying to combat. We hope that schools selling Back2Tap bottles for a fundraiser do so with the understanding that they are promoting sustainability and environmental stewardship as well as raising funds.

In sum, there are numerous significant differences between cheap, low quality reusable bottles and better more expensive stainless steel water bottles. If you buy an inferior bottle that doesn’t last or doesn’t get used, your effort to be “greener” or live more sustainably will have failed – so don't even bother!  A good reusable bottle can save you hundreds of dollars over its lifetime so it is worth investing in a high quality bottle that you will enjoy using every day.

Comments (6)

  1. Toni Ranieri says:

    Since I already purchased and used my cheap stainless steel water bottle from KMart, what I need to know is whether it is unhealthy to continue to drink out of. There is a seam. I'm trying to research it, but with little success. If you know or can lead me in the right direction to find out, I would appreciate it.  Toni

    • admin says:

      Hi Toni,
      I would first try to contact the manufacturer (by law there has to be a way to do that communicated on the label) to ask what type of stainless steel it is made out of. There are many types of stainless, and I’d be happy to help you figure out if your bottle is a safe type, such as Type 304. As far as the seam goes, all stainless steel bottles have seams so that’s not necessarily a problem unless it is improperly finished. You should also check the inside/outside of the neck and lip of the bottle to make sure they are smooth. Also, if the neck isn’t wide enough, believe it or not, a child can get a tongue stuck in the bottle! That also makes it virtually impossible to clean. So if it has a narrow neck or if the neck is lined with copper, I’d recycle it and buy one of ours! Even if the neck and lip seem OK, cheap bottles are very thin and they dent quickly and the caps often leak. All in all, I suspect you’ll get annoyed using it long before it has a chance to poison you!

  2. Jenny says:

    somehow came across your blog while browsing for a article for a class, but I have to say I’m happy I found it …will definately subscribe sometime.

  3. Buy Wow Gold says:

    I was very pleased to find this site. I hope to thank you for this good article: Stainless steel water bottles are not all created equal! | Back2Tap .I really like your blog, I have bookmarked it. Hope that you will keep up with good work, your article is very absorbing. I wish you have a nice day!

  4. Amy says:

    There are definitely some stainless bottles that are better than others. I like the ones that are rust-free and dishwasher safe.

  5. Cheri says:

    Thank you for the great blog! Remember any time that you consider water, tap water is the best option for your health and environment.

Leave a Reply to Amy

Before you post, please prove you are sentient.

What is 7 times 8?